I’ve been on the East Side long enough now that I’m part of its history in a minor way, which is a strange thing to notice. The couple who ran the hardware store on Wayland Avenue knew my name. The people who have replaced them don’t, but the store is still there, which is not nothing.
The neighborhood has gotten more expensive in ways that are visible and more uniform in ways that are harder to articulate. The visible part is the real estate: houses that sold for reasonable amounts when I arrived are now priced for people with considerably more money than I had when I arrived, which has changed who moves in and, over time, what the neighborhood expects of itself. The less visible part is something like a narrowing of range — fewer of the slightly odd small businesses, fewer of the people who are here because the rent was manageable rather than because the neighborhood was desirable.
None of this is unique to the East Side or to Providence. It’s the story of walkable urban neighborhoods in mid-sized American cities over the past twenty years, and it has a reasonably well-understood set of causes. Knowing the causes doesn’t make the texture loss less real.
What remains: the physical fabric of the neighborhood is intact in a way that it isn’t in a lot of comparable American cities. The houses are still the houses. Benefit Street is still Benefit Street. The Brown campus is still an awkward presence at the top of the hill, town and gown negotiating the same tensions they’ve been negotiating for two and a half centuries. The waterfront, which was an industrial ruin when I arrived, is now a genuine amenity. The RISD Museum is as good as it’s ever been.
I don’t know what the East Side will be in another twenty-five years. I know what it is now, which is still, despite everything, a good place to live. That’s not nothing either.